Sensors & Detectors, compared honestly
A data directory, not a ranking: 12 products by what actually matters — compatibility, subscriptions, and the catch.
Sorted by how much we’ve verified — a statement about our research, not a ranking of the products.✓ works · ◐ partial · ✗ doesn’t work (verified) · ? not checked yet
Motion Sensors (4)
| Product | Alexa | Apple | SmartThings | Home Asst. | Sub? | ~Price | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| IKEA MYGGSPRAY Wireless Motion Sensor | Alexa: works | Google: works | Apple: works | SmartThings: works | Home Asst.: works | no | $9.99 |
| Aqara Motion and Light Sensor P2 | Alexa: partial support | Google: works | Apple: works | SmartThings: works | Home Asst.: works | no | $34 |
| Philips Hue Motion Sensor (indoor) | Alexa: works | Google: works | Apple: works | SmartThings: partial support | Home Asst.: works | no | $49 |
| Eve Motion (3rd generation, Matter) | Alexa: works | Google: works | Apple: works | SmartThings: works | Home Asst.: works | no | $55 |
Contact (Door & Window) Sensors (4)
| Product | Alexa | Apple | SmartThings | Home Asst. | Sub? | ~Price | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| IKEA MYGGBETT Door/Window Sensor | Alexa: works | Google: works | Apple: works | SmartThings: works | Home Asst.: works | no | $9.99 |
| Aqara Door and Window Sensor P2 | Alexa: works | Google: works | Apple: works | SmartThings: works | Home Asst.: works | no | $30 |
| Eve Door & Window (3rd generation, Matter) | Alexa: works | Google: works | Apple: works | SmartThings: works | Home Asst.: works | no | $44 |
| SwitchBot Contact Sensor | Alexa: partial support | Google: partial support | Apple: partial support | SmartThings: not checked yet — not a claim about the product | Home Asst.: works | no | $17 |
Presence Sensors (2)
| Product | Alexa | Apple | SmartThings | Home Asst. | Sub? | ~Price | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| SwitchBot Presence Sensor | Alexa: works | Google: partial support | Apple: partial support | SmartThings: partial support | Home Asst.: works | no | $29.99 |
| Aqara Presence Sensor FP2 | Alexa: partial support | Google: partial support | Apple: works | SmartThings: not checked yet — not a claim about the product | Home Asst.: works | no | $83 |
Temperature & Humidity Sensors (2)
| Product | Alexa | Apple | SmartThings | Home Asst. | Sub? | ~Price | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| IKEA TIMMERFLOTTE Temperature/Humidity Sensor | Alexa: works | Google: works | Apple: works | SmartThings: works | Home Asst.: works | no | $9.99 |
| SwitchBot Meter Pro | Alexa: works | Google: works | Apple: works | SmartThings: works | Home Asst.: works | ◐ optional | $30 |
Every cell links to a sourced research profile with the caveats. Prices are research-time notes, never live. Check against your setup →